Skip to main content

NYC Korean Food: Okdongsik's Dweji Gomtang vs Seoul Salon | USA East Coast Series

After days of lobster, butter and pasta, my Asian soul woke up again. 🥢

 The moment I landed in NYC, I needed rice, broth and chilli. With the city's huge Asian population, quality is never in short supply. Let's start with Korean.


1. Okdongsik 🥇

Okdongsik
Busy night on weekday with a small queue
Gomtang simply means a bone broth simmered for hours until it turns rich and gentle. It's traditionally made with beef. Dweji means pork, and pork broth is the pride of Busan, where post-war refugees turned cheap pork bones into the city's beloved dwaeji gukbap. It's humble, restorative, everyday food.

Okdongsik New York
Typical Korean meal set up, kimchi tasted good
Chef Ok Dong-sik built his name on stripping that bowl right back: one perfect pork broth, clean rather than heavy. Then Netflix's Culinary Class Wars (흑백요리사) put him on screens worldwide, and the queues followed.

Okdongsik New York
Love this dwaeji gukbap

🍽️ Food & Drinks 

A short queue on a weekday evening, around 20–30 minutes. Worth it. The broth is clear yet deeply flavourful, the portion is generous, and it tastes properly authentic. The kimchi is excellent too. Very reasonable for what it is.

Okdongsik New York
Decent kimchi tofu dumpling


👋 Service & ✨ Decor 

It's bar seating, so there isn't much service to judge, but the staff are seriously efficient and the space is clean and tidy. You come to eat, not to linger.

💰 Value 

Great quality at a fair price. Pro tip: if the queue looks long, order takeaway and skip the wait entirely.


2. Seoul Salon 😐

🍽️ Food & Drinks 

After Okdongsik, I was keen for more. Seoul Salon sits on the edge of K-Town and is in the Michelin Guide, so expectations were high. We didn't book but managed to grab a bar table.

I ordered the two signatures. The scallop rice was decent: nicely seasoned rice, but the scallop itself lacked flavour. Fine, but nothing to write home about.

Seoul Salon
A ok scallop rice, as a scallop lover, this is really average.
The fried chicken was a proper let-down. It isn't typical Korean fried chicken and the batter is something else entirely. Even judged on its own terms, the chicken was under-seasoned and dry. Crispy, yes, and that's the only compliment I can give it. The gochujang sauce was too salty with no real layers of flavour.

Seoul Salon
Big disappointment, crispy but lacking flavour. 

👋 Service & ✨ Decor 

Very modern, busy and popular, and the service was good throughout.

💰 Value 

Prices are reasonable, but the meal was just average. I'd go elsewhere next time.

Verdict 🏁 Okdongsik delivers a superb, authentic bowl worth queuing for. Seoul Salon looks the part but the food doesn't follow.

Ratings ⭐

Okdongsik

  • Food: 4.25/5 – Clean, deeply flavourful pork broth with a generous portion and excellent kimchi.
  • Service: 4/5 – Bar seating with fast, efficient staff.
  • Decor: 3.5/5 – Clean and simple, built for eating rather than lingering.
  • Value: 4.5/5 – Very reasonable for the quality on offer.
  • Overall: 4.25/5 – Worth the queue, or grab takeaway to skip it.

Seoul Salon

  • Food: 3.5/5 – A decent scallop rice, but bland scallops and dry, under-seasoned fried chicken.
  • Service: 4/5 – Attentive and good throughout.
  • Decor: 4/5 – Modern, buzzy and popular.
  • Value: 3/5 – Fair prices, but an average meal.
  • Overall: 3.5/5 – Looks great, tastes ordinary.

💰 Estimated cost per person: Okdongsik £20–£30 | Seoul Salon £25–£45 


📍 Okdongsik 

Address: 13 East 30th Street, New York, NY 10016, USA

📍 Seoul Salon

Address: 28 West 33rd Street, New York, NY 10001, USA

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

2026 Ultimate Food Guide for Tokyo Haneda Airport (HND)

I make every single calorie count before I head to the gate. Haneda Airport has leveled up significantly in the last couple of years—it’s no longer just a place to grab a sad sandwich. Between the new Haneda Airport Garden and the classic Edo Koji upper deck, you can actually have one last world-class meal. The Lay of the Land: Where to Eat? There are two main "foodie" zones before you hit security: Haneda Airport Garden: The shiny new wing connected to Terminal 3. Edo Koji (4F Departure Hall): The classic "Old Tokyo" themed street right above the check-in counters. 1. Edo Koji (4F Departure Lobby) This is where the energy is. It’s styled like an Edo-period street and has some of the most famous airport branches in Japan. Yakitori Soba Nishaku-gosun is a solid choice for those looking for a reliable meal at a decent price. Located on the 4th floor of the Terminal 3 departure hall, it offers a straightforward dining experience that won't break the bank before you...

A Joy -Taipei's Highest (and Priciest) All-You-Can-Eat Truly Worth the Sky-High Bill?

When someone mentions "buffet," your mind probably conjures up images of lukewarm, vaguely-Chinese food trays and a general sense of regret. But hold onto your chopsticks, because East Asia’s buffet game is a completely different. We’re talking next-level quality, and prices to match. This time, Honest Bao scaled the ultimate peak in Taipei to review what might be the city's highest and most expensive buffet... and I'm here to tell you if it's the absolute best. Great view on Taipei city This place is seriously popular, so ditch your spontaneous dinner plans. You must book in advance, and here's a cheeky little catch for you international travellers: they tend to charge foreigners a tad more since you typically have to use a booking agent like Klook to snag a spot. Once you're in, though, prepare to be impressed. The restaurant sprawls across the entire floor, and the variety of food is absolutely monumental—it easily dwarfs any buffet spread I've enco...

The Farmer’s Dog Review: Is Jeremy Clarkson’s Pub Actually Worth the Hype?

Alright, foodies, grab your wellies. Remind you Jeremy Clarkson is the owner Today we are going for a journey deep into the Cotswolds - checking out The Farmer’s Dog, the highly anticipated country pub opened by Jeremy Clarkson. With thousands of glowing reviews plastered all over TikTok and Instagram, I rolled up expecting a literal culinary miracle. The reality? It’s a cracking good feed, but it might just be a tiny bit of a victim of its own massive internet hype. Nice character building Let's start with the positives: the food here is genuinely lovely. We are talking proper British comfort food, served up in absolutely massive portions that guarantee you won't leave hungry. Best of all, for a place attached to a major celebrity name, it actually won't break the bank. Nicely cooked and tender pork rib Let's start with the positives: the food here is genuinely lovely. We are talking proper British comfort food, served up in absolutely massive portions that guarantee y...